Transcribed from a list in the Church guidebook written by Derek Taylor Thompson, Churchwarden, available in the church.
| List of incumbents of Nutley, East Sussex | |
| 1847 | John Dalison |
| 1848 | J P Power |
| 1851 | William Powell |
| 1855 | H B Lennard |
| 1857 | Thomas R Turner |
| 1860 | W E Hutchins |
| 1868 | Albert Smallpiece |
| 1872 | George G McLean |
| 1882 | Harry J Peckham |
| 1913 | Charles Neill |
| 1916 | John Phillips |
| 1932 | Stephen Pulford |
| 1940 | Peter Walkden |
| 1954 | Fisher Ferguson |
| 1957 | Christopher Flack |
| 1969 | Leslie Shone |
| 1973 | Gordon Rideout |
| 1979 | Geoffrey Berry |
| 1988 | Kenneth Boullier |
| 1994 | Michael Bulman |
06/01/2007 | Transcribed by Mark Collins |